Defeating John Cena for the United States Championship in his debut match: This was a huge shock and instantly established him as a top heel.
Winning the Intercontinental Championship from Shelton Benjamin: Another quick championship win after being drafted to Raw.
Unifying the WWE and World Tag Team Titles with his brother Primo at WrestleMania 25: A significant moment for the Colóns as a tag team.
His rivalry with "The Nature Boy" Ric Flair: This feud produced some memorable segments and matches.
Hosting "Carlito's Cabana": A popular talk show segment that allowed him to showcase his charismatic and "cool" persona.
His appearance at WrestleMania 21, interrupting Roddy Piper and receiving a Stunner from Stone Cold Steve Austin: A classic, iconic WrestleMania moment for Carlito.
His return at WWE Fastlane 2023, joining Rey Mysterio and Santos Escobar: A highly anticipated and impactful return
Being a part of The Judgment Day: His recent involvement with the faction has provided new, interesting moments.